Making Fictional Worlds Feel Real Part 3: Research Realism

Do you know what one of the biggest dangers in writing fantasy can be?

Using🪄 Magic™  to explain everything you don’t know anything about.

Believe me, it’s tempting.

Occasionally, necessary.

And sometimes, kind of fun.

But I set out to write about a team of criminal investigators.

It doesn’t matter that the criminals they chase might be werewolves, or vampires, or … whatever.

They still have to investigate crime scenes. Collect evidence. Interview witnesses. Interrogate suspects. Perform autopsies.

And whatever conclusions they draw from all that have to make sense.

Otherwise, what is even the point of it being urban fantasy?

If I didn’t make it believable, I might as well set it in some old-timey made-up fantasy world of swords and sorcery where they could have some magical means of seeing inside bodies or whatever makes sense for that.

So when I created a pathologist, I needed to know all five stages of an autopsy. I needed to know what pathologists look for. How time of death is established (it’s never as precise as you see on TV, by the way. It’s a lot more ballpark than that!)

I had a blood splatter analyst, so I needed to know how much blood was in a human body, and how much they could lose before they passed out. And how much they could lose before death was certain. I needed to know what blood looked like in snow. How it aged.

I needed to know how crime scenes were processed. Who went in first. Who did what. Who collected what.

I needed to know what they looked for.

What they would see.

I needed to know how it smelled.

That’s where my brain had to go when writing the very first chapter of Blood in the Dust, when Yip stumbled over the scene of a brutal murder.

Yip has a deeply traumatised past. It wasn’t some convenient back story for her: I gave her a horrific history for a purpose.

If you’ve experienced the kind of trauma Yip has, you get good at certain things. Reading people. Seeing where danger comes from.

I borrowed from a lot of my own trauma for that, but obviously, I didn’t experience what she had, so I did a lot of research into body language and what it can tell you.

I’ve been very careful to present it not as “science”, though: it’s never as black and white as “He looked down and to the left, therefore he was lying.”

Of course not.

It’s always more something that Yip notices, and her experience helps her interpret it as a possibility. Not a certainty. The point of the research wasn’t just “what’s possible” but to find the limitations of what it can do.

Still… she’s usually right. 😏

When Yip is injured in Blood in the Ferns, I spent hours and hours researching what that injury might have felt like for her, what complications came with it, and what her recovery would be like.

And she doesn’t miraculously jump up and keep fighting after getting injured. She goes down hard and stays down, because that’s what happens in the real world.

Yeah… sometimes, it was just… Magic™🪄

But even then I wanted it to make sense.

Werewolves can heal their injuries almost immediately — but only if they’re properly nourished. They need calories to heal.

Watch how snacks become weirdly important as the series goes on.

And there’s that scene where Reese determines where one of Norman’s quillacues came from … by tasting it.

But Reese is a wight. A ghoul. And a scientist.

So it does make a kind of sense that they would be able to taste certain chemicals in the body of the deceased they consume.

These little departures from reality usually happened when there was either existing lore I needed to explain—like how werewolves can heal so fast—or a problem I couldn’t find any other solution to. (Reese, you legend!)

But mostly, I tried to stick to the real world.

Did I sometimes spend hours researching the construction of a chair to write a single sentence that ultimately I didn’t use?

Sure.

But did it make the book better?

That’s the goal.

Next
Next

Making Fictional Worlds Feel Real Part 2: Cultural Realism